A barrier gate is built to control who enters a lot. It is not built to stop a vehicle that has decided not to stop. That distinction, long understood by security engineers, reached a much wider audience in January 2026, when a driver crashed a car into the departures area of the McNamara Terminal at Detroit Metropolitan Airport. For parking operators and facility managers who run gated entrances, the follow-up deserves attention, because the questions it raised apply well beyond airports.
What happened at Detroit Metro
The crash occurred on Friday, January 23, 2026, according to the airport’s reporting. Local coverage and an industry commentary published February 3 by the president of bollard manufacturer Delta Scientific both describe the vehicle striking a ticket counter inside the terminal. Accounts differ on injuries: the manufacturer’s piece reports six people hurt, while one local news report of the airport’s later briefing says no one was injured. Treat the casualty figure as unsettled and rely on the official investigation for it.
What is consistent is the airport’s response. Officials placed roughly 9,000-pound concrete barriers at the terminals in a staggered arrangement, and described them as temporary while a permanent solution is studied. The airport’s chief executive said the incident “has definitely changed our security posture.” Officials also noted that engineers and architects need to be consulted before anything permanent goes in, because the McNamara Terminal’s tiered design could create new problems of its own.
One point worth stating plainly: we found no published plan or timeline for a permanent retrofit. The “retrofit” so far is a set of temporary concrete barriers. Anything beyond that is still under study.
Why this matters outside airports
Airports and stadiums are the places most people picture when they hear “vehicle barrier.” The federal government’s guidance takes a wider view. CISA’s April 2024 Vehicle Incident Prevention and Mitigation Security Guide analyzed 347 vehicle ramming and vehicle-borne explosive incidents between 2002 and 2022 across several countries. Its guidance says these attacks need minimal capability but can be devastating in public gathering places with little visible security, and it lists sidewalks beside critical infrastructure, open-air markets and other public venues among potential targets. It also records water and wastewater utilities reporting damage from vehicles smashing through perimeter gates.
CISA also states that a mitigation strategy “cannot be a one-size-fits-all approach,” and that no guidance will deter every attack. For a hospital entrance, a university plaza, a hotel porte-cochere or a downtown parking structure, that means the question is not whether to copy an airport. It is whether the building’s own layout, glass line and pedestrian queues create a predictable weak point.
Where gated lots are exposed
Parking operators tend to think of vehicle threats at the gate lane. The Detroit crash was at a building face, which is a reminder to look at three places.
The entrance lane itself
A standard barrier arm is a traffic-control device. A typical arm is lightweight, and its job is to hold a queue, not absorb impact energy. If a gate protects something that truly needs vehicle-stopping capability, such as a utility yard or a secure compound, the arm is not that protection. See our overview of bollards paired with barrier gates for how the two roles are separated in practice.
The pedestrian edge
Ticket counters, pay stations, entrance doors and waiting areas sit behind curbs or open apron space. Industry commentary after Detroit stressed that decorative bollard covers are not deterrents, and that protection has to come from tested, certified systems rather than appearance. That matches the ratings framework we cover in ASTM F2656 crash ratings.
The service and emergency openings
Gaps left for accessibility, deliveries and emergency vehicles are where a layout breaks down. Any barrier plan has to keep lanes usable for operations and first responders, which is why many sites combine fixed protection with removable or retractable units at the openings.
Active barriers at gated lanes
Where a lane must stay usable, the answer is usually an active barrier rather than a fixed one. Retractable bollards, wedge barricades and beam barricades are the families industry commentators point to for lane control, because they let authorized traffic through and stop everything else. CISA publishes a barrier selection spreadsheet for active vehicle barriers, and its crash-test standard for vehicle security barriers is the reference point for comparing products. The important habit is to compare ratings on the same basis. A product described as “heavy duty” or “high security” has told you nothing until you see the tested rating, the foundation it was tested on, and the vehicle used in the test.
It also helps to keep the roles clear in procurement documents. A barrier gate that manages access and a crash-rated barrier that stops vehicles can sit in the same lane, but they are specified, installed and maintained as different systems. Mixing them up is how a site ends up believing it has protection it does not have.
Practical steps before spending anything
- Map the approach paths. Walk the site and note every route a vehicle could take to reach a door, a queue or a pay station, including routes that bypass the gate lane entirely.
- Ask for the rating, not the look. Any product offered as a vehicle barrier should come with a tested crash rating. Unrated planters and covers look protective and are not.
- Check what the ground allows. Utilities and slabs limit how deep a foundation can go. Shallow-foundation and surface-mounted products exist for exactly these retrofits, though their ratings differ from deep-set units.
- Treat temporary barriers as temporary. Detroit’s own officials framed their concrete units that way. A staggered temporary layout buys time for proper design, and it should come with a date for that design work.
- Use CISA’s free tools. The agency publishes a self-assessment tool and an action guide aimed at owners and operators, which is a sensible way to prioritize locations before engaging a barrier supplier.
Most facilities will never face a deliberate attack, and CISA’s guidance also covers accidental incursions, which are far more common in a parking environment. The practical takeaway from Detroit is narrower and more useful: walk your own entrance as if a vehicle will sometimes go where it should not, and find out whether anything between the curb and the people is actually rated to stop it.

